facebook

Urban Rehabilitation in Portugal

Between the duty of maintenance of private owners and compulsory works imposed by municipal authorities.

The need for urban rehabilitation is not recent and continues to be of great importance, particularly in areas experiencing significant urban pressure and in ageing urban areas. The existence of deteriorated, vacant or poorly maintained buildings is not merely a problem for their owners, as it poses a risk to the safety of persons and property and necessarily contributes to the shortage of housing available on the market.

The right to property is constitutionally enshrined and naturally carries with it certain duties. It is not sufficient for the owner to have full use of the property. They are also subject to the inherent duties of maintenance and are required to take the necessary measures to ensure adequate safety and health conditions on their properties. Therefore, alongside the duty of maintenance imposed on property owners, it is necessary to grant municipalities the necessary powers of supervision and intervention in situations of non-compliance with this duty.

The issue will always lie in striking a balance between what is considered to be the State’s interest and the protection of private property: in what way and to what extent can the powers granted to municipalities require owners to carry out works on their property, and when does such an imposition amount to excessive action on the part of the public administration?

It was with this intention in mind that the legislator, through Decree-Law No. 307/2009 of 23 October, and subsequently through its successive amendments, has sought to reconcile the duty of building rehabilitation incumbent upon private owners with the public responsibility to supervise situations requiring urgent maintenance. Indeed, Article 6 of that legislation begins by clarifying that property owners have a duty to ensure rehabilitation, namely through the execution of works necessary for the maintenance or restoration of safety, health and aesthetic conditions.

In turn, municipalities, or the managing entity to which they have delegated such functions, have the duty to promote the designation of urban rehabilitation areas within their municipalities, namely areas consisting of deteriorated or obsolete urban spaces in which there is considered to be a need for the municipality to exercise control operations. They may assess the condition of buildings through inspections and surveys carried out for the purpose of fulfilling their duties.

Within the scope of these inspections and surveys, and depending on the condition of the property, the municipal authority may impose on the owner the legal obligation to rehabilitate the building and determine the works that must be executed. For this purpose, the owner must be notified of their obligation in accordance with the law, and the works to be carried out and the deadline for their completion must be specified, always in accordance with the criteria of necessity, suitability and proportionality.

Where the owner fails to act, either by failing to commence the necessary works or by failing to complete them within the prescribed deadline, the municipality may take administrative possession of the building and execute compulsory works, thereby replacing the owner.

In such cases, and following the completion of the compulsory works by the municipal authority, if the owner fails, within a maximum period of four months, to fully reimburse the expenses incurred, the municipality may lease the property through a public tender for a period of five years, renewable. However, the owner has the right to object to the conclusion of the lease agreement and may instead request the forced sale or expropriation of the property, with the amount of the expenses incurred in execute the works being deducted from the amount payable to the owner.

Alternatively, the municipal authority may proceed with the sale of the property by public auction to the highest bidder who undertakes to comply with the rehabilitation obligations imposed within the established deadlines. However, the owner has the right to sell the property to a third party and may also submit a reasoned counter-offer to the amount proposed by the municipal authority for the sale of the property. In the event of a forced sale, the municipality pays the owner the amount obtained at the public auction, while disputes must be governed directly by the Expropriation Code.

The possibility of execute compulsory works constitutes an important instrument of urban policy. A façade at risk of collapse, a deteriorated roof or equipment installations that compromise the safety of a building may endanger not only its occupants but also pedestrians and neighbouring buildings. If the Public Administration could only order works to be executed, without having mechanisms to respond to non-compliance, the duty of maintenance would risk becoming, in many cases, merely a hypothetical situation.

However, compulsory intervention does not mean that the municipality has unlimited discretion. The Public Administration remains subject to the principles of legality, proportionality and the pursuit of the public interest. The duty of maintenance cannot be used as a basis for indiscriminately imposing any intervention that the municipality considers desirable. There must be a relationship between the condition of the property, the deficiencies identified and the works required, duly supported by technical criteria. However, the fact that works are executed by the municipality does not mean that the corresponding expenses must be borne by public funds. The legal framework provides mechanisms allowing the recovery of costs from the owner, in accordance with the applicable provisions. This solution is justified: if the duty of maintenance lies with the owner and the owner has failed to fulfil it, it would not be reasonable to permanently transfer to the community the cost of a private obligation.

The fact that the owner does not have sufficient financial resources does not eliminate the legal duty of maintenance. Financial difficulties may, however, be relevant when considering the available solutions and coordinating them with any existing rehabilitation support mechanisms. There are situations in which the deterioration of a building results from a combination of economic and social factors, particularly in ageing urban areas, old buildings or areas subject to strong property-market pressure. In such cases, a policy based exclusively on the imposition of obligations may prove insufficient. Therefore, urban rehabilitation requires not only supervision and compulsory instruments, but also incentives, financial support and mechanisms that make it possible to carry out the necessary works.

About the autor

Start typing and press Enter to search